My opponent won fair and square and was very mannered. I tried to report the game but the only option I found was to report the player which obviously is not what I want to do. So I put this here.
My question: Why did the score estimate calculate the exact same territory (visually) with a 5 points difference (changing the result from a win to a loss for white).
I learned a lesson to count myself, but I feel like I made some lazy moves because score estimate told me I was winning no matter what the last 10 or so moves. I did not expect the AI to trick me at the very least
I mean, even after the game is over and I lost, I still have a 97% win chance according to OGS AI.
I am not mad but curious at what is going on here.
I have reported the game as “Other,” because it needs to be annulled as a wrongly scored game. It is either an example of the autoscore bug from 2020, or it was score cheated. I agree that the latter seems unlikely because your opponent has a clean record over at least the last 100 games. A mod will be able to tell the difference definitively.
Yeah it seems like the stone removal algorithm didnt pick up those 2 stones as dead, and then you both accepted the score like that. Its good to check up the board and manually mark the dead stones / territories before accepting if needed, usually the algorithm gets it right but not always ://
Game has been annulled so it wont affect your ratings ^^
I thank you for doing to the right thing and reporting the game. I think I would do the same most of the time. Because obviously something was wrong.
But I have now reviewed our first pass. I declined the score after surprisingly realizing I somehow lost. I thought I must have missed something. The score estimator said c13 stones were mine in the review (win for me) but I obviously missed it in the end score review (where it wrongly changed).
So I missed it twice, but the score estimator also tricked me twice. And my opponent also must have missed it twice, or was trying to cheat me. And I don’t think he/she tricked me. Objectively, I don’t think it matters - bottom line I didn’t see the OGS mistake.
OGS score estimate is almost certainly at fault, but if I was more alert I would have found it. I got two chances and failed. I don’t think my oppponent should be punished for a silly score estimate glitch? I don’t know how I would feel if this happened vs two random people. I would probably report it as unfair and a glitch/bug, but not annul the game if I’m being honest.
