Discussion about R17

At position R17, @Timonph started the conversation:

classic

( FYI @GaJ )

@BrucePee said:

Why is 5 only considered good and not ideal?

( FYI @GaJ )

@gennan said:

Because black’s response at P16 gives black a good result?

( FYI @GaJ )

@gennan said:

And by “good”, I mean better than even.

( FYI @GaJ )