Ditch the Square: Why Circular Profile Pics Are The Future

Just wait for the Circular Baduk Boards, rather than bowls there are four pockets

4 Likes

Yes yes. Round board, square stones.

6 Likes

I remember (perhaps from Martin Gardner) Piet Hein being keen on such superellipses, though I thought I remembered him calling them something else, and preferring some exponent around 2·5.

Rectangular stones pls!

Squircle perhaps?


BTW, I‘ve been using a circular avatar image for a quarter century now :sunglasses:

1 Like

11 Likes

Against a black background, I am wondering whether my profile pic aka avatar is circular or square.

Scherm­afbeelding 2024-10-02 om 19.50.03

5 Likes

Hmm considering submitting a PR for this during Hacktoberfest. Is this actually a popular suggestion or just a meme? (fwiw I really do prefer the circular profile pics)

  • I prefer circles
  • I prefer squares/rectangles
  • I prefer squircle
  • I don’t care
0 voters
1 Like

I don’t think that any changes should be made. The current square avatars can be made to simulate circles or other shapes by utilizing transparency.

Putting a circle inside of a square does not lose any available space. However, if it were the other way around, trying to simulate a square avatar (using transparency) within a circular cropped image, then one would lose space.

Thus, currently circular (other shaped) avatars are already supported with a simple workaround. Changing to a circular cropped avatar by default would limit flexibility and options.

4 Likes

As you can see here, cropping my avatar down to a circle actually clips the outer circles

Yeah that’s fair, glad I asked!

Heh the inconsistency between OGS proper and OGS Forum will continue to bother me :upside_down_face:

1 Like

Mostly it’s because discourse does discourse things haha

2 Likes

We could change it on Discourse.

4 Likes

It would be useful if default was square, but with a button that instantly crops your avatar to a circle.

6 Likes

What if there were a user setting that changes how all profile pictures are displayed to that user?

And that would just change how everything’s rendered:

1 Like