Rengo status

OGS Development
1154

I’m on my way, just detained slightly still, by an ogre that won’t die.

2 Likes
1155

The rengo scoring bug is even worse than we knew. Leaving the tab open does not work. The system changes the acceptance to non-acceptance after about one hour, even with the tab open.

1156

If anyone would be willing to write a sequence of events I can use to reliably create the “scoring bug” that’d get me off to a good start.

TIA

1157

-2 teams of players play a casual rengo game

  • it finishes, both the same teams pass
  • one team accepts the score
  • this is recorded in the game log, but it disappears visually if that player leaves the tab and apparently after one hour
  • if the other team accepts the same score, the game ends with that score
  • if not, players are, one by one, eliminated by timeout

Probably related: I have seen 4-5 times the timer stuck at 0.0, but it doesn’t happen always and I don’t know why.

Here a recent example. It ended when aga3d accepted the score but I timed out before that.
I think it’s not as bad as it seems, but still something that can be improved

5 Likes
1158

Thanks. I can immediately envisage a situation where the score clock makes the game clock stop for “black” and “white” but not “the other players”, or something along those lines…

I think this has been a Thing since before Rengo…

4 Likes
1159

Thanks! Would be nice to see the gamelog on what happened there ^^

1161

another case of rengo game doing something weird in scoring, i think my last remaining teammate already marked the stones properly and accepted it, but then they timed out and the suggested score got all wonky again.

1 Like
1162

This is now totally the next thing on my list, may have a chance to look on the weekend.

7 Likes
1163

Fix submitted.

7 Likes
1164

But it doesn’t work?

Or is it only for new games?

1165

Hasn’t been deployed yet, AFAIK … its with anoek.

2 Likes
1166

Ah, excuse me.

1 Like
1167

That’s in now :slight_smile:

1 Like
1168

Emh, I don’t see that black accepted the score here :sweat_smile:
Only new games?

1 Like
1169

Should be in all games … back to the drawing board eh

2 Likes
1170

I tested this both locally (on my own machine) and here on the main server, and it seemed to work.

Let’s be on the lookout for other examples: I haven’t been able to see a failure happen myself.

1171

scoring system still suggests all stones on the board being alive 友谊赛

1172

The problem in the game you cite is not particular to rengo. That appear to be the autoscore bug from 2020, which is now increasingly occurring in non-rengo games (assuming that someone did not mark the dead stones alive).

1 Like
1173

It might be only correspondence: here I don’t see that black accepted the score. Same here and here

2 Likes
1174

When trying to launch the ai review on finished rengo game