Oh I thought it was your role
Yes
So, what do you actually think about what has been said? After being absent for most of the game day, I hope you have more to say than just that. I see you had already cast a vote to kill no one.
Actually I think the best option is to:
A- Reveal roles by end of “day” then think who to kill.
or
B- Let the detective do the work .
Regular.
So there is a competing role as Detective?
@Leira
Please change your vote to detective on the poll, to make it clear.
Currently, both @Leira and @李建澔2 have claimed to be the detective and they have both already voted to indicate such in the poll.
1 Like
@李建澔2
Please take away your vote as innocent.
1 Like
I already canceled it
1 Like
To clarify:
Competing Claims:
李健澔2 and Leira are competing for Detective.
HHG, ginger2008, and yebellz are competing for Innocent.
1 Like
So, I see. As expected, there are two competing claims for detective. I believe @yebellz has us covered for this contingency?
EDIT: I mean, whatever I say is a liability.
In addition, @李建澔2 has claimed to have investigated and cleared @HHG as innocent.
I think we should kill @李建澔2 today (Day 2).
If @李建澔2 is a Robot, then we will certainly win the game. Since then @Leira would be the true Detective, who would be protected by @Gia on Night 2, in order to investigate one of the three players claiming innocence (@ginger2008, @HHG, @yebellz). That will either find the last Robot or narrow it down to two, which means that we would be able to kill the last Robot on either Day 3 or 4.
If @李建澔2 turns out to actually be the Detective, then we would confirm that @Leira is a Robot and @HHG is innocent. @Leira would be killed on Day 3, and the remaining Robot must be either @yebellz or @ginger2008. In this contingency, I would of course know that @ginger2008 must be a Robot, however, whether we win the game would depend on who the rest of the players believe.
I wish more people would try to reason through possibilities.
Questions:
What does everyone think we should do?
Would not killing today give us a better chance to win?
2 Likes
So, everyone has revealed their roles and claimed now. Who do you want to kill? And why?
Well, what do you say that we do? We might wind up soon confirming you as either innocent or a robot. Either way, it would be good to have everyone on the record.
Why do you say that investigating would be useless? What do you think we should do? Should we kill someone today? Who do you suspect?
1 Like
Anyone.Either way, our chance of winning is higher.
What I mean by this is that, obviously I would advocate to lynch (for lack of a better word) @李建澔2. That would put us on a winning position. But that is tautological, since I guess I would prefer that if I was a robot. This is exactly what I meant by 50-50 gambit, though I guess it’s not exactly 50-50. It seems somewhat inclined in our favor, maybe 75-25?
1 Like
@yebellz reasoning is sound. So if we have to decide between killing @李建澔2 and killing @Leira today, I’m for 李建澔2, because they seem more suspicious to me.
1 Like
I’m still not sold on Leira.
And if they are indeed a robot, I will be suspicious tomorrow of whoever supported them.
@Leira, if we kill @李建澔2 and he is actually a robot, please don’t let this make things awkward while I’ll be guarding you tonight.
3 Likes
I’m not solid on both of them (well, that’s just part of the game 
), but I think yebellz is right and we don’t have much to lose.
3 Likes
@Haze_with_a_Z are there two detectives in the game or only one ?Or is there a robot detective and normal detective because I found it out in game 3?just to make sure thanks for replying
Yeah. Plus, his brawl stars addiction is a bit annoying.
李建澔2, there are two detectives in the game, a robot detective and a normal detective.
1 Like
Everyone please remember to vote:
There are two “detectives”, one is a Robot and one is an innocent. However, as innocents, we have not been focused on tracking down the Robot detective, since their impact has been nullified by everyone just revealing roles. In all of the discussion above, we have been trying to determine who the Innocent Detective is. Are you the Robot Detective? Was that the cause for confusion?