Analysis mode triggered too aggressively during conditional moves

When planning conditional moves, I usually want to move back and forth between the different moves in a branch to review whether their placement is realistic or whether I actually wish to play that way.

However, recently, if you press any key while in conditional move planning, it will switch you over to analysis mode. It feels a bit sudden to first be in one mode and planning moves, and then suddenly be switched to analysis mode. It feels unexpected and not entirely logical.

I’m on experimental site mode in Firefox 141.

3 Likes

Hello,

In “Conditional moves” mode, until a few days ago it was possible to use the back and forth arrows to navigate in the conditional tree.

For instance, I could enter a possible opponent move, enter my response, then go back two moves by clicking the back arrow two times, and enter a different possible opponent move and my response to that.

But now, if I click the back arrow, OGS immediately closes the “Conditional moves” mode, and gets into “Game analysis” mode.

As a side-effect, the changes to the conditional tree are saved and become effective immediately, something that normally doesn’t happen until I click the submit button of the conditional moves mode.

3 Likes

Just trying to keep the related issues together, hopefully we can get them solved soon @anoek @GreenAsJade :slight_smile:

3 Likes

Yuk, that’s a nasty bug!

This part of the code has had some recent changes, so it’s not surprising to find a bug of this nature (unlike some of the other recent problems reported, which are still “mysterious”).

5 Likes

This should be fixed now

3 Likes

Also noting that the “mysterious issues” is also (in theory :slight_smile: ) fixed.

1 Like

Im still noticing this bug. Specifically, when i hit the “prev move” button under the board, the conditional moves get saved and the board enters analysis mode

IIRC it used to remain in conditional moves mode

1 Like

The bug is still there for me too.

2 Likes

Does it also happen when you hit back-arrow, or is it somehow "fixed for back-arrow, but broken for “prev move” button?

(I’ll try it out myself as well as soon as I get a chance, but it does help to know what you experience as well!)


Just to confirm: I can reproduce this: our e2e test for it confirms: still a problem.

It appears that only “first, last, back 10 moves” got the fix, not “back one, forward one, forward 10”.

1 Like

I’m on mobile, so arrow keys are N/A

1 Like

I just tried it on Firefox on Ubuntu. Arrows also switch to Analysis mode.

1 Like

Just checking in on the status of this…

Just starting correspondence play on OGS, the conditional move feature seems like a great way to move things forward. But if the “conditional move entry ↔ analysis mode” bug is still out there, perhaps I’ll refrain from trying to enter conditional moves for now.

Anyone know where this issue stands? Thanks!

It takes roughly the same effort to try it out as to write a forum post :face_savoring_food:

Seems to be fixed for me

1 Like

Likely so. But being a newbie and learning the ropes, I didn’t want to wander off into analysis mode during a ranked ladder game. Perhaps being overly cautious.

Good to hear it’s working for you. Maybe I’ll just forge ahead.

1 Like

To follow up: I did just enter a couple of conditional moves on a correspondence (ladder) game. Stepped back and forth through the potential moves. No analysis mode was triggered. If that was the behavior of concern, it seems to be fixed. All’s well that ends well. :+1: