I like this better, because the blues on both players are as similar as they can be while remaining readable.
Except that there’s a concern that this is less readable
So it’s “color consistency vs readable”.
Bhydden has a point that this is hardly the most important thing we can focus on, but on the other hand it’s easy and accessible … and it still irritates me
I opened the contest (and even made a video showing how to experiment with the colours) and nobody responded (despite the votes above) so my conclusion is that these opinions aren’t something you all strongly care about
Are you not understanding about player card colours, or player name colours?
RedAgent was referring to the yellow/gold player name that you also referred to, which perhaps doesn’t stand out so well against the white player card in the dark theme (on the game page).
FWIW there are also purple, green and grey player names (at least. maybe more).
Hmmm, now I’m really confused! I don’t know what a player card is but I noticed that player names are either normal or yellow or purple! That’s all I need to know, right?!