Werewolf Game 4: Madness of the Martian Mimics

[Samraku]

↔:zombie:

[Samraku]

[yebellz]

Nice work, @RubyMineshaft! It goes without question that @Starline should be voted out today.

It seems that @Samraku (taking over for @Sports_for_Life) has now been affected by MED!

I’m having trouble deciphering what they might be saying.

• No idea what the first line etc means
• The second line seems to be about @Cool_Person, and maybe mentions Sports?
• The third line is also indecipherable to me

@Cool_Person could be a mimic only pretending to be a bodyguard, but their allegiance should become obvious tonight, since they should die tonight protecting @RubyMineshaft. If @RubyMineshaft is killed instead, then we will know that the last mimic is @Cool_Person.

After we kill them, if @Starline turns out to be innocent (which is unlikely in my opinion), then we would know that @RubyMineshaft was a mimic.

[yebellz]

Actually, maybe this

@Samraku

means “Kill @Starline”?

I think we’ve been using to denote @Starline

But I think would be even more clear

[Assai]

Good morning everyone!
@Samraku:
There is a small dictionary already

---

We now are 8 astronauts against two mimics and will vote out another mimic this evening (I think that is what @Samraku tried to say).
That also means we will be 7 astronauts against one mimic tomorrow! We almost won. We know @RubyMineshaft will reveal another role to us tomorrow or we will know @Cool_Person lied and is the third mimic.

[yebellz]

@Assai

We now are 8 astronauts against two mimics

I think there are only 9 of us left (7 humans, 2 mimics)

1. RubyMineshaft (claimed to be detective)
2. HHG (innocent according to Ruby)
3. Cool_Person (claimed to be bodyguard)
4. Samraku (replaced Sports_for_Life)
5. Assai
6. KAOSkonfused
7. yebellz
8. ginger2008
9. Starline (mimic according to Ruby)

If we kill Starline as a mimic, and Cool_Person dies tonight, we will be left with 7 people tomorrow (6 human, 1 mimic):

1. RubyMineshaft (claimed to be detective)
2. HHG (innocent according to Ruby)
3. Samraku (replaced Sports_for_Life)
4. Assai
5. KAOSkonfused
6. yebellz
7. ginger2008

Best case would be that Ruby finds the last mimic, but at worst, he will confirm another person as innocent. Either way, we can kill the last mimic, @ginger2008, and win the game.

[HHG]

@Starline, what do you have to say in defense of yourself? I mean, Ruby’s probably a detective (a) Why kill one of your own, b) If they were an innocent, they are lucky.)

[yebellz]

Some interesting observations about @Starline’s past statements

@Starline

Mimics:
Sports: 85%
Vagabond: 80%
Cool Person: 50%
Assai: 25%
Haze: 15%
Fiddlehead: 10%
Kaos: 10%
Yebellz: 5%
Gia: 5%
Ruby: 5%
HHG: 5%
Starline: 5%
That adds up to 300%, right? Yeah.

“Forgot” to mention ginger altogether

@Starline

This narrows it down, to these players, of which exactly 2 are mimics.
Haze with a Z
Sports for Life
Cool Person
Assai
KAOSKonfused
yebellz
ginger2008
Starline

Subtly puts their self and ginger at the bottom of the list

@Starline

Final mimic standings:
Gia: 99%
ginger2008: 53%
Sports_for_Life: 44%
Assai: 36%
KAOSkonfused: 35%
Haze_with_a_Z: 9%
Starline: 8%
Cool_Person: 8%
yebellz: 8%

Finds ginger to be highly suspicious, but their reasoning

@Starline

I have a few suspicions about ginger2008:
On the second day (!), when the detective would only have gathered whether one person was evil or not, they wanted the detective to reveal. This is exactly what a mimic would do. ginger2008 also says, very strongly sometimes, that we are doing this, we are doing that, etc. I feel like this is also what a person, who is not on “our team” would say.

seems highly contrived, and almost seems like a deliberate straw man argument for someone else to knock down. Prior to this post, @ginger2008 had only used the word “we” a few times:

@ginger2008

So know we know that there are 11 good, 3 evil.

@ginger2008

And who said we are going to lose??

@ginger2008

But if we pretend yebellz was a mimic, he is acting, so you are fooled

“Pretend” is an interesting choice of words. A human would be uncertain, but a mimic would have to pretend.

[KAOSkonfused]

Good morning everybody! *KAOS smiles* I’m feeling sooo much better now! Finally I can again!
*looks around* Wait, where is ? Has Haze disappeared? Oh no… So that means he really was a , uhm, bodyguard, and he died while protecting Ruby!

*turns to Ruby and Yebellz*
So - I was right to suspect Starline? He really is a mimic?
Now, thinking about what he said before, I am even more convinced that Cool is the remaining mimic - and not ginger.
Like I said - or tried to say - yesterday: I think Cool lied about being a bodyguard. Actually, Gia already admitted that Leira was the other bodyguard, when she said yesterday:

@Gia

So, I will offer all of you a trade: don’t kill me today, and I will reveal one of my team to you. You’ll only lose your other bodyguard, and they signed up for it.

[HHG]

I think we should kill Starline, investigate Cool (If they get killed (mimics kill person to investigate) => they are innocent, if they are the bodyguard, it’s the same as if the mimic(s, depending on Starline) attacked Ruby. If they are innocent innocent, why would they do a false claim? If they are the mimic, Ruby is dead (assuming the bodyguard is dead, by Gia’s words), but we deduce that Cool isn’t the bodyguard (unless he doesn’t protect Ruby?) we won.)
Whoops, thanks Ruby.

[RubyMineshaft]

Sports was replaced, not Cool

@Vsotvep

@Samraku is playing the role that @Sports_for_Life had.

[Assai]

My mistake, I counted Sports_for_Life. But that also means I misunderstood a little bit what Samraku said:

@Samraku

I think he referred to last night. We lost one innocent astronaut (Haze), but we also got rid of a mimic (Gia).

[Samraku]

↔:pirate_flag:

[HHG]

Cool_Person is a mimic? I think we should kill Starline (who we confirm to be a mimic), and investigate Cool (who we think is a mimic).

[yebellz]

@HHG

investigate Cool (who we think is a mimic).

We don’t need to investigate Cool tonight, even though we might suspect them.

Most likely Cool will either die tonight (confirming that they are indeed a bodyguard protecting Ruby) or Ruby dies (confirming that Cool is a mimic). If both Cool and Ruby stay alive, then the mimics would help us by reducing the suspect pool and we get another investigation for free, so that only improves our situation.

Ruby should investigate one of the other players, which will be useful for us if Cool dies and Ruby lives.

@Samraku, I’m not sure what you are saying. Can you trying using some other symbols to help clarify?

Innocent

Mimic

[Samraku]

[RubyMineshaft]

Im still confused by your MED speech.

Is inspect?

[ginger2008]

@RubyMineshaft

Good morning, crew. I hope everyone slept a little bit better last night, knowing that we’ve purged one of these things from our midst. I feel terrible that @Haze_with_a_Z gave his life to protect me of all people, but he gave his life for the good of the mission and the survival of the human race. We should have a moment of silence.

Ruby falls quiet for about a minute. His eyes scan the room before coming to rest on Starline.

By the way, @Starline is a mimic.

@RubyMineshaft , if you don’t mind, please inspect me next night. I am a innocent with no abilities. I don’t want to die!

[Samraku]

[Samraku]