Werewolf Game 4: Madness of the Martian Mimics

Forum Games
121

You NEED evidence before making a choice! Otherwise, you will most likely wind up killing one of your own. Do you not understand that?

6 Likes
122

@yebellz I changed my vote because Haze With A Z seems more suspicious than you. Also He posted a lot so that is giving me a feeling that he might be evil. I sort of was convinced by him but now I think Haze is Evil.

123

@Cool_Person you’re saying that whoever posts the most is suspicous? Where do you get that from?

1 Like
124

no I said he might be evil not he is evil. I never said he was Evil, I just think he is evil for other reasons not just posting a lot.

125

Since I know I am not evil, I am reading this post as “I know Haze isn’t evil but I am going to say this anyways”, especially because of this part: “I said he might be evil not he is evil. I never said he was Evil”.

I am not saying that cool is definitely evil, and it is their first game and so I don’t know how they are trying to play, but I would like to know why they think this way. If they don’t have a reason, I think that they are evil.

3 Likes
126

@Haze_with_a_Z I have a reason why I think you are evil. You are saying you arn’t evil so I think you are lying. This is my first game and I am trying to play by looking for clues that someone might be evil.

1 Like
127

What are your other reasons besides “lying”? @Cool_Person
What is your defense? My vote is on @Cool_Person
Whoever is evil will obviously lie and say they are innocent?
So that is no real evidence. Are you guessing?

1 Like
128

:+1:

2 Likes
129

It is a reason if they think I am lying. Basically a gut read. I am not going to shut down someone’s gut read, even if I know that it is wrong. If you care so much, have the detective check me. They will find out that I am just an innocent astronaut, and not one of those pesky mimics.

I can’t get a whole lot from Sports, but I don’t like how he is completely shutting it down. The astronauts are allowed to share who they think is who, even if it is incorrect. While more evidence is better, at least they have something and not a vote like “I think that you have a stupid reason for voting x so I am voting you” when you don’t even have any more evidence then that. I don’t like your vote justification, Sports.

3 Likes
130

If it is a gut read by @Cool_Person then I respect it. And they can say that instead of just saying they have their reasons. @Haze_with_a_Z
I would like to hear from @Cool_Person if it is a gut read. If she has no comment then i am still suspicious.

2 Likes
131

Please, let’s calm down. Cool_Person, you do not have any evidence that Haze is evil, besides voting patterns (not very useful, as currently (I think the other times were by accident / testing)), that don’t really work.

6 Likes
132

Ok

1 Like
133

@Cool_Person is it a gut read or not?

2 Likes
134

A gut read

1 Like
135

@Vsotvep, I was wondering, why is the “nobody” option in the poll in italics?

2 Likes
136

Ok @Cool_Person you’re saying that you just have one reason for believing haze is evil?

2 Likes
137

I have voiced my suspicions regarding Haze and Gia. Now, I suspect HHG of being the third mimic. Granted this is purely speculation at this point, but for the sake of discussion, here are a few things I find curious:

A plea to calm down and not vote for Haze. At the time this statement was made I happened to see a rather interesting person nodding her agreement. Check the security footage, it’s all there.

Was this a Freudian slip?

I am torn about our best course of action. On one hand, I think it would be best to exercise caution as lives hang in the balance, and no one comes back from being vaporized. On the other hand, we have a lot of crew members; removing a mimic on day one could be worth the risk of executing one of our own, as distasteful as it sounds.

As it currently stands, no one will be executed today. I think this is probably for the best considering our very limited amount of evidence. However, I will be switching my vote from Haze to HHG in order to let the official record show my suspicions.

6 Likes
138

Question. If one of us is the enemy, are all of us the enemy? Does it matter what person shows up as clear? Such as if you guys actually believe me and acknowledge that I am an innocent astronaut that was supposed to be on board, does that make the others more/less suspicious? I think that Gia is innocent, although I do not yet know about HHG. Will it change anything when you guys finally realize that I am innocent? If HHG or Gia turns out to be a mimic, will you suddenly be more convinced that I am one too? I am not a mimic. I don’t know how to convince y’all of that, but I am not. The detective can check me if you don’t believe me. I am innocent.

Also, although I do find Cool suspicious, I like their argument on me. I like your argument on me. Even if I don’t like how you two, and probably others are falsely lumping me into the mimic group. The one thing I will ask is if you are coming up with people you think are enemies, don’t try and group them too quickly.

6 Likes
139

I don’t know why but my brain thinks yebbelz is evil

2 Likes
140

To clarify, I merely find the three of you suspicious. Being suspicious of someone does not mean that I am convinced they are guilty. Since it’s currently pure speculation, I don’t think we should execute any of you tonight.

3 Likes