Did you even read what James found out?
James investigated me, then Ye Bellz, and claims both of us are innocent.
I’m starting to suspect Roy more of lying than James, on virtue of being so frantic about this whole affair.
1 Like
By James claiming that he is the oracle, that automatically makes me a “soulsnatcher”. Simple as that.
2 Likes
Because a fake oracle would have two reasons for claiming to be an oracle:
- Spreading confusion
- Finding out who the real oracle is.
I’ve even said earlier, that the real oracle shouldn’t immediately come out after you started claiming to be an oracle. It gives away their identity to the soulsnatchers.
If you claim Haze is a soulsnatcher, and James is the real oracle, they can be pretty sure Haze is innocent, or else you wouldn’t have claimed that Haze was a soulsnatcher.
As for the plan, that was a lie. I would claim to investigate the same person, but in reality investigate Leira. This would put me 1 whole day ahead of James.
It’s hard to make it seem legitimate you know?
Why would you investigate Leira?! If you’re the actual oracle, you can now be 100% sure Leira is a soulsnatcher…
Sorry, but you’re making absolutely no sense to me, I’m voting to kill Roy.
2 Likes
And with that I think I figured out all 3 soulsnatchers.
1 Like
And with that, you confirmed that you’re a soulsnatcher to me 
Not just to me, but to everyone in fact: You have claimed already that you investigated me and that I am innocent. James also claimed that I’m innocent. There is no reason for the real oracle to withhold the information that someone is a snatcher.
By now accusing me of being a snatcher, while you know I’m not (if you’re the oracle you know, and if you’re a snatcher you know), you’ve given me the certainty that you’re lying.
1 Like
I think you’re suspicious, too. Roy, you are not making any logical sense.
Frankly, if we have to lose because our oracle is behaving erratically, so be it.
I assume what you said here will be ignored?
Now that you’ve accused me of being a soulsnatcher, I’m 100% sure that you’re not the real oracle, so that is indeed irrelevant to me.
Given that Roy is a soulsnatcher, we can be pretty safe in assuming that Hazel is innocent. Since there has been no counterclaim to Maze’s claim to be a witch, I’m fairly certain Maze is innocent as well. Both Hazel and Maze are voting for Roy, which supports this assumption as well.
James investigated both me and Ye Bellz, thus we are innocent as well.
That means that the remaining two soulsnatchers are under V. Solis, Kayo, Papa Roheas and Vagabond.
AND MARLON!
Forgot about him…
First: if the protector is one of the remaining four suspects, they can confess to being a protector, bringing the number of suspect down to three (but don’t do this, it’s not necessary, and I could still be wrong about Hazel / Maze being innocent).
Our witch can kill one of the remaining four suspects, and we could assume the soulsnatchers kill the lovers, meaning we’d start tomorrow with a worst-case scenario of 2 soulsnatchers, 6 innocents, of whom 3 suspects. We’d vote out one of the three suspects, have another innocent killed at night, bringing us down to a worst-case scenario of 2 soulsnatchers, 4 innocents, meaning all suspects are soulsnatchers, and there are enough innocents to win every vote.
We can use the oracle to speed this up by confirming the role of one of the players, and if the lovers die tomorrow, then the protector could potentially speed it up more by revealing themselves, since my mistake about Hazel / Maze would become irrelevant. But neither of these things are necessary to force a win.
So, I have a proposition to the soulsnatchers:
Given that you have been cornered, there is no reason to spill any blood. Why not reveal yourself right now, and allow us to save you? We could visit an exorcist to nullify the magic talismans, relieving you of your curse.
Do you accept this offer of peace, or will you fight on to your inevitable death?
I think we both know what the soulsnatchers will answer: fight.
1 Like
1 Like
Oh, shoot, you’re right!
Upon recalculating, it looks like we can’t guarantee a win after all… But we have a huge advantage at the moment!
I still believe the witch should kill one of the suspects. The problem is that we have too many suspects, and we can only guarantee the oracle staying alive for one more night (if the protector is killed tonight, and the oracle tomorrow night). If the oracle survives two nights, we should be able to win still.
2 Likes
What a revelation! So it appears that we now have a confirmed oracle. I agree with the proposed plan for the protector to remain under cover and protect the oracle. Our strategy from now on should be to kill any soulsnatcher confirmed by the oracle at day. If no new soulsnatchers are found we should abstain from killing at day, right?
I am not completely sure yet…
1 Like
Well, if we are to vote out someone tomorrow, or if the witch wishes to use his killing potion, i am going to express my biggest suspects in order of suspiciousness (with 1 being the most suspicious):
- Gia
- Vagabond
- Kingkaio
- Sanonius
- Kaoskonfused
But we don’t know the other snatchers, this doesn’t make sense.