New experimental nav bar available

Hi All,

We’ve got a new experimental navigation bar available that we’d like to see how y’all like before deploying it for everyone. It looks something like this:

It’s overall a bit taller for most devices, though if you have a short screen it’ll collapse to be the same height as the existing bar. The bar will also collapse to a hamburger type menu when the window is narrow (like you’re on a mobile device for instance).

You can opt in to this experiment by flipping the “Enable experimental interface changes” toggle under Settings → General Preferences

image


For those that enable this, let us know what you think!

  • I prefer the new nav bar
  • Either nav bar is fine
  • I prefer the old nav bar
  • I don’t like either (and will provide some ideas for improvement down below!)

0 voters

15 Likes

On my mobile phone I see on the menu the list of tournaments and the list of ladders in which I am involved. Scrolling down those lists may be tedious if they are long.

6 Likes

height of new nav bar is too big, “space is wasted” feel spam my thoughts

4 Likes

I voted for the new nav bar, I think it’s much cleaner and seeing the search directly is a BIG plus. However I hate all the dynamic sub-menus, especially the tournament list as already mentioned by jlt.

5 Likes

link to profile and settings should be also be in menu, not only inside secret button that looks like your name
people will ask about it

also, since there is free space in narrow window now, maybe place Search line here anyway?
or mobile users will continue to ask that the most popular question

6 Likes

Funny, that’s been the number one complaint I’ve heard about the current nav system, that the settings/logout stuff is not in the right menu, but rather “hidden” amongst the other stuff

5 Likes

Good idea but I prefer the old nav bar. I can’t find anything more to say. Maybe it is better for mobile devices, not using via phone. Still even there is no option to change, no one would quit the server. Not that kind of change. But I like OGS community becuse of this, it is always developing and has a forum that is asking thoughts of the users. Sorry to discover this place late. I also would like to see the ratings that has been gained and lost attached to each game in the game list on the profile. Just like lichess has. These are all I am going to say when I have a chance to contact the coder boss of the website. I still wouldn’t discourage you by saying it is too bad. I liked it but prefer old nav bar. Thanks for everything.

2 Likes

I think it’s okay, but forums should have more prominent button.

6 Likes

in new hamburger menu titles of category are below buttons
it would be more logical if buttons were below category names

7 Likes

On desktop, at least, this is a big improvement. Many thanks.

9 Likes

on more practical aspects:

it should have collapsed height anyway because currently Go Board size became smaller for no reason.
also on narrow screen if its not long enough, score graph may be partially not seen

1 Like

Chat needs its own place on the bar. D:

1 Like

I like it. Certainly prefer this logic than the previous one.

At first glance, what @jlt said and also where’s a home button… I’d like to be able to return to home from anywhere (I’m that person, what can I say).


I think the move circle that is now the move thingie doesn’t work properly, I currently have 8 moves and it shows zero.

Update: seems to work now.

5 Likes

I like the new bar (I am using a notebook). But I think Tools could be merged under Learn and I miss a direct link to my profile on top right.

3 Likes

mobile users have to click 2 times to go to play page
they will play less often because of that

3 Likes

Could we have some customizable “sticky” menu items up top, like home-play-forums?

(I have no idea how things work, please disregard if impossible)

5 Likes

While I agree rather we should minimize clicks to play, I don’t think the number of clicks has changed in this update?

I need one click on desktop, two on mobile with both…

Edit: this is what I see

2 Likes

I made window as narrow as possible and still see Home and Play

2 Likes

I’m not against new menu.
My usage is a little worse with it, though.
Tournaments and groups take too much space. Maybe they could be collapsed.
Lines wrapping make it even bigger.
Also line spacing is too big.

And it’s harder to find the link for the forum!
I like Gia’s proposal of sticky customizable items: forum on top would be my choice.

And why is “Play” title below its categories while “Tournaments” is above the tournaments list?

6 Likes

maybe also replace words with icons?

1 Like